We will name police and social workers unless action is taken, Southport families lawyer says
Legal representative highlights systemic failures in preventing attack
Chris Walker, the legal representative for the families of three murdered girls, has stated that individuals involved in the Southport attacks will be publicly identified unless appropriate disciplinary measures are implemented. The victims—Bebe King, six; Elsie Dot Stancombe, seven; and Alice da Silva Aguiar, nine—were killed by 17-year-old Axel Rudakubana during a Taylor Swift-themed dance class in June 2024.
“There are five particular state entities which are causing us most concern,” Walker said, adding, “their behaviour is unacceptable. We find their performance to be totally unacceptable.”
The public inquiry concluded that “catastrophic” failures occurred due to parental and local authority shortcomings, with a recurring cycle of referrals, assessments, and handovers between agencies failing to halt the “predictable and preventable” attack. Walker emphasized that if disciplinary actions are not satisfactory, key figures from the five involved agencies will be named.
The agencies under scrutiny include Lancashire Police, Lancashire Social Services, the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service (CAMHS), and the Forensic Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service (FCAMHS). Prevent, a Home Office initiative, was also cited, as it struggled to grasp the concept of “ideology” and failed to apply it effectively to cases like Rudakubana’s.
“Prevent have a real issue with understanding the word ‘ideology,’” Walker noted. “They’ve failed to implement the ideological consequences or understanding in their various gateways. The desire to cause mass murder must be prevented, regardless of the cause.”
The inquiry revealed that no agency or multi-agency structure took ownership of assessing the “grave risk” posed by the attacker. Rudakubana’s autism was used as an excuse for past behavior, leading to a lack of awareness of the danger he represented. Inquiry chairman Sir Adrian Fulford urged an end to the culture of agencies shifting blame or downgrading their role in such cases.
Walker, who has been in communication with the agencies, plans to follow up on the inquiry’s findings to ensure disciplinary proceedings meet the families’ expectations. He described the current situation as a “horror movie,” with the families reliving the trauma each time new reports emerge. “Every new incident brings them back to the same horror,” he said.
Phase Two of the Southport Inquiry will commence immediately after the 760-page Phase One report. It will examine the adequacy of systems to detect and manage risks from individuals fixated on extreme violence. Walker criticized the “glossy book” of recommendations, stressing that without meaningful action, the cycle of disasters will continue.
Listen to the best of BBC Radio Merseyside on Sounds, and follow BBC Merseyside on Facebook, X, and Instagram. Share story ideas via Whatsapp at 0808 100 2230.
